We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you. Companies like Birchbox or Ipsy are known for bringing a degree of personalization to online health and beauty shopping. There are often discounts or promotions that allow you to snag these products for less than you would find at the store, and they also offer free gifts with purchase that make it worth your while to shop the Birchbox site instead of, say, Sephora. Ipsy, on the other hand, will, Purchases from their online store (1 point for every $1 spent), Referral of friends and family to their own subscription service (50 points), ​In the past, subscribers used to have the ability to earn points by leaving reviews for products. The selection of bonus items varies depending on availability and popularity. Moink vs Butcher Box [2020 Comparison] – Which One Should You Choose? Learn more About Us & our process. We actually ORDER each box before we review and recommend products because we believe nothing beats FIRST HAND experience. Here’s the scoop: While Birchbox does sell cosmetics and makeup. Both claim to provide boxes with values above and beyond what you pay in your $10 per month fee, but what does the value come out to be for Birchbox vs. Ipsy? What sort of products are you most interested in testing? Review AdvisoryHQ’s Terms for details. Companies like Birchbox or Ipsy both offer very similar services but with slight variations in the types of products they carry. Some people find themselves waiting for their first glam bag for two months or so, but several bloggers, including Kristin Magaldi at Cambio, have said that taking advantage of social media can help to speed the process along. I received a lot of the same samples from month to month – I’ve been sent the same shampoo and eyeliner twice. Both subscription boxes have a type of points system, where you gain points by performing certain actions and can redeem them on their sites for different products. Birchbox has paired the idea of the subscription box with an online shop that sells full-sized versions of the deluxe makup samples you receive in your box (and many others.) Total value of the bag well exceeds the price you pay, especially when full-size products are included. Now that you know the basics of companies like Ipsy or Birchbox, we will take a closer look at Ipsy vs. Birchbox to help you decide which one is better for you. Original review: Sept. 9, 2020. Birchbox offers shipping only in the USA, whereas Ipsy also sends cosmetics to Canada too. Image from Millennial Gal. I have had a lot of people ask me, “Which beauty subscription should I choose? I also like the way that Birchbox allows you to choose one of your samples each month, so you know for a fact you’re getting at least one thing you really wanted. When your package does finally arrive, a lot of consumers prefer the packaging that Ipsy has to offer. Basically Birchbox wins. Similarly, Birchbox vs. Ipsy will also vary in terms of the size of the items within the boxes or bags. When most people my age think of commitment, they are probably thinking of marriage or their careers but the first thing that comes to my mind is how long I’ve been committed to my monthly beauty subscriptions. Below you can find a breakdown of each box to determine which one is right for your personal preferences. Because Birchbox for men offers an entirely unique service, Birchbox may be a winner in the debate between Ipsy or Birchbox. Note: Firms and products, including the one(s) reviewed above, may be AdvisoryHQ's affiliates. Usually one or more full-size items per box, Chooses all samples for you, but has a more detailed questionnaire, Offers discounts and promotions on popular brands, Offers generous discounts to be used on brands’ websites.