If you're not looking for an emergency substitute but a purer, richer flavor, the best replacement of all for ground nutmeg is to buy the whole spice, and grate it fresh whenever it's needed. The flavors in nutmeg and other spices come from a range of perishable flavoring compounds, and some of them are so volatile they'll disappear in a matter of a few hours. Best Nutmeg Substitutes The highest quality whole nutmegs will have a high percentage of volatile oils, for super flavorful cooking. This is a fall favorite, and it is actually a blend of nutmeg, allspice, ginger, and cinnamon. This content is created and maintained by a third party, and imported onto this page to help users provide their email addresses. Ground Nutmeg Substitute. Pumpkin pie spice. There's no "fresh" nutmeg. Once ground, the volatile oils in allspice berries dissipate quickly, losing their flavors after a few weeks or months. Nutmeg, on the other hand, can be described as weaker. Much like what's sold in the jar, but may be be fresher and have more flavor . The flavor between mace and nutmeg is a bit different. Now reader amt230 has a good question about fresh ground nutmeg.Should recipes calling for ground nutmeg (presumably not fresh) be adjusted when using fresh ground nutmeg? You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io Advertisement - Continue Reading Below. You can even use ginger, mace, allspice or cloves as freshly grated nutmeg substitute. Source(s): ground nutmeg substitiute fresh nutmeg: https://shortly.im/Fkgcy. Lv 5. Or dried and left complete and packed for grating. Mace. The nutmeg can either be dried and grated fresh. 1 decade ago. However, if you have just run out of it, you can just use these nutmeg substitutes to add a similar flavor. Can anyone tell me how to substitute ground nutmeg for fresh nutmeg? Traditionally, this is made fresh with the spices ground just before use. Cinnamon is the most common substitute. It makes a good substitute for nutmeg when used in small amounts: Start with half the suggested amount of nutmeg and taste as you go. It seems like nutmeg week around here! It will give you the fresh, fragrant, and flavorful nutmeg for every use. I recently made a vegan pumpkin icecream and used freshly ground nutmeg … With a unique flavor, nutmeg has made its mark as a spice in a large number of dishes. 0 0. lazylazymo. Nutmeg is usually used in dessert recipes, savory dishes like cheese sauces, soups, meat and potato dishes. Mace is spicier and stronger. If you're totally out of nutmeg or your ground nutmeg has been sitting on the shelf for far too many months (or years! Whole nutmeg is a hard nut that you have to grate very finely. First we talked about the nutmeg grinder we love, then Emma gave us the full scoop on this common spice. Depending on the region from where it comes, the spice mix may be dry roasted before grinding. The best substitute for ground nutmeg is ground cinnamon. However, you can also purchase pre-made garam masala. It’s similar to the mix of pepper and cinnamon. Best Nutmeg Substitutes. It has a similar sweetness to cinnamon but stronger.